Release the Lebanese
Detainees in Syria Now!
|
Boston, Massachusetts
January 16, 2005 |
In the winter of
2003, when the Baathist regime in Baghdad was about to collapse on the eve
of the American invasion, Saddam Hussein's henchmen carried out the
elimination of thousands of political prisoners that were held in his
prisons. Most were executed and buried in mass graves for fear that they
may live to tell their stories. After the defeat of the regime, only the
haunted rooms and torture chambers of the regime's prisons and dungeons
could tell what those stories may have been during more than three decades
of Baathist rule in Baghdad.
With the
prospects for a makeover of the political landscape in the region, hopes
are running high that human rights will become a central tenet of
governance in that part of the world, along with democracy and
institutions. Unfortunately, the immediate focus of all efforts appears to
be on elections as the primary measure of the spread of democracy. No
attention is paid to the other basic freedoms and to human rights. One can
argue that elections are the necessary first step on the road to achieving
those objectives, but unfortunately, those who have languished in jails
for three decades do not have the luxury of waiting for elections and duly
elected governments. Change, albeit in the right direction, operates on a
geological time scale that ordinary individuals, especially those whose
freedoms are denied and their families cannot afford.
Both the Syria
Accountability and Lebanese Sovereignty Restoration Act and UN resolution
1559, in spite of their good intentions and their aim at liberating
Lebanon from under Syrian Baathist rule, paid only lip service to the
rampant human rights abuses suffered by the Lebanese people under the
Syrian occupation. Most importantly, they completely ignored the fate of
thousands of Lebanese nationals who, for no reason whatsoever other than
the simple vulgarity and wantonness of a sadist political system that
thrives on fear and abuse, ended up locked up in Syria's jails. Now that
the capitals of the West have admitted what they knew all along, namely
that their sponsorship of the Syrian "presence" in Lebanon was in fact for
a bona fide occupation, what are they waiting for to begin
reversing the most inhumane aspects of an occupation: prisoners of
conscience, victims of the practice of enforced disappearances by Security
and Intelligence Services and the assassinations of journalists and
diplomats, pillars of the culture of death and oppression that were common
in Eastern Europe under the Stalinist regimes and that have been the
staple of Arab dictatorships for several decades?
Often seized in
their homes or disappeared from the streets of Lebanon, these prisoners
were transferred from holding cell to holding cell inside occupied Lebanon
before being illegally extradited across the border and jailed in the
notorious prisons of Syria (Mazze, Tadmur, etc...) without any semblance
of due process (no attorney, no court, no next of kin notification, secret
detentions...). The reasons for their arrest and disappearance range from
ordinary everyday incidents that turn into nightmares, to a patriotic and
vocal opposition to the occupation, and to military personnel who were
fighting the Syrian army while under orders of their superiors in the
Lebanese army. As an example, a car accident between a Lebanese civilian
and a Syrian Army truck becomes enough of a reason for the civilian to be
locked up in Syria for 20 years. Or a soldier in the Lebanese army who
carried out his orders on the front line and fell in the hands of the
Syrians, but instead of being treated in accordance with the Geneva
Convention spent 15 years in a Syrian jail. Or a civilian Lebanese who
happened by chance to drive by a Hezbollah training camp was seized by the
militia and handed over to the Syrians who transferred him to Syria for
years and years. Many never came back. Many died and their bodies returned
to their loved ones under seal and under strict orders not to open the
coffins. According to Syrian political dissenters who have escaped to the
West and are speaking up for the first time, many of the Lebanese
prisoners, and no doubt prisoners of other nationalities as well, are
believed to have been used as Guinea pigs in Syria's chemical weapons
programs testing fields. What is worse is that after the 1990 toppling of
the last free Lebanese government, all the puppet governments that
succeeded each other in Beirut have denied the existence of the detainees.
When pressured by the families of the detainees, the Lebanese government
twice set up inquiry committees who have yet to release their reports or
their findings.
According to two
prominent NGOs, the Lebanese SOLIDE (Support for Lebanese in Detention and
Exile) and the Franco-Lebanese SOLIDA (Support for Lebanese Detained
Arbitrarily), there are at least a few hundred known cases of Lebanese
nationals who are currently held in secret detention in Syria, but whose
existence is denied by both the Syrian regime and its Lebanese puppet
government. In a couple of notorious cases, even as the Lebanese and
Syrian governments were denying the existence of specific cases that were
brought to their attention, the prisoners in question were suddenly
released, demonstrating either one of two things: Either the Syrian
government no longer knows who it is holding - very often the prisoner is
given a new name in the prison so that no one knows that they even exist
under their real names - or the Syrian regime is lying and refuses to
acknowledge the existence of these hundreds of Lebanese prisoners.
As the era of
Baathist rule in Syria comes to an end, there is great fear that the
Syrian regime is "cleaning up" its torture chambers before its sordid
record is exposed to the world. There is fear that the prisoners are being
eliminated in the same fashion that the regime of Saddam Hussein
eliminated its own prisoners. There has to be an immediate and concerted
action by the West to place this issue on the top of its list of demands
from Syria before it is too late. Moreover, the issue of the Lebanese
detainees in Syria has become a lightning rod for all the frustrations and
the anxieties of the past three decades for the simple reason that it is
the most obvious and egregious violation of human rights. There can be no
academic discussions about its validity as a human rights issue. There is
no official hostility between Syria and Lebanon so that prisoners can be
released as part of a deal to be negotiated. No one can argue any
political motives for either the detentions themselves or the demands for
the release of the detainees. As such, a release of the detainees could
speed up reconciliation and healing. Otherwise, it could turn out to be
the Achilles heel of any attempt at reconciliation or for the Lebanese
people to establish any friendly relations with Syria once the Syrian
occupation ends and it turns out that the Syrians did in fact commit the
unthinkable against thousands of innocent Lebanese civilians.
The cries of
anguish of the families of the detainees continue in Beirut. They have
staged every march and demonstration. They have sought the help of every
international organization and government. They have gone to the Syrian
border asking for an audience with the Syrian dictator, only to be rebuked
and sent back. They have staged sit-ins at the offices of the UN in
Beirut. They have nowhere left to go to demand an accounting for their
children, their husbands and their brothers. Only yesterday they launched
a new campaign aiming at sensitizing the rest of an anesthetized Lebanese
society as well as the international community on this issue. Eight
Lebanese flags are being circulated in Lebanon, France and the United
States to collect signatures on them and then turn them into petitions
demanding the immediate release of the Lebanese detainees from Syria.
At a press
conference at Lebanese University this past week, the families of the
detainees explained their latest move: "Our children are being tortured in
Syrian jails for more than 15 years now. It is simply unacceptable that
nothing is being done to set them free. This is a humanitarian issue of
concern to all Lebanese, regardless of their affiliation. Our children
must be freed immediately", said Violette Nassif, a member of the Families
Committee whose son, Johnny was captured on October 13, 1990 as a soldier
fighting the Syrian invasion under military orders.
The key
compelling objective is now for the the US, France and the UN to recognize
that by declaring the Syrian "presence" in Lebanon an occupation they have
assumed the consequences of what an occupier did and does to its occupied
victim. As such, the world must act immediately and with great urgency to
bring the issue of the Lebanese detainees in Syria to its only
humanitarian conclusion: An accounting of all those Lebanese detainees who
are alive in Syria's prisons and their immediate release, as well as an
accounting of all those detainees who were killed inside the torture
chambers of Bashar Assad and his father Hafez. Nothing short of that will
cleanse the conscience of those who, after remaining silent for so many
decades over the rape of Lebanon by Syria, have come now to recognize
their monumental mistake and have begun taking action to make up for this
outrageous crime against decency and international law. The human factor
is at the core of the question of the Lebanese detainees in Syria, and it
must therefore take equal standing with, if not precedence over, the other
issues of regional peace, the war on terrorism, the development of weapons
of mass destruction by Syria, and the liberation of Lebanon for the Syrian
occupation.
|